
Illusion of Communication
Because this blog is about many things, but mostly about my intercultural relationship, I wanted to make sure that at least one of my blogs posted today focused on that.
So, I’m taking two of my recent bullet points and writing one blog on them. Essentially they are related.
- There was recent drama between my vahini (Bear’s brother’s wife) and my in-laws.
- There is a slight vie for control over our lives with his parents.
Where to begin?
Hmmm, this one is easy and yet it’s tough as well.
You see, the biggest problem that we as humans have is in being truthful with ourselves and other’s when it comes to the really tough subjects.
We can be truthful about the type of Jelly/Jam we like. We can have major disagreements over Crunchy or Smooth Peanut Butter. Argument can happen over crust on or off. But actually being truthful to someone who loves a Peanut Butter and Jelly sandwich that you loathe PB&J, that you hate them with a blinding white passion or that they just make you feel all icky and stuff. Well, that can be a hard thing to do. Especially when you know that person loves his PB&J.
Just so we understand here, I am using PB&J as a synonym. Just so we are both on the same page. We are? Ok, so moving forward.
I won’t go into too much detail about what has happened between Vahini Bhabhi and our husbands parents, but needless to say it was a melee.
Either way, the words used or how they were expressed isn’t what’s important here.
What lead up to the encounter IS what’s important.
One person said something in a way that made the other person take it entirely different than the original meaning or intent. All because the first person didn’t express exactly what their meaning was. This usually happens because we are afraid of how the other person is going to take what we say. Being politically correct with loved ones usually turns into disagreements or feelings of being unloved or misunderstood.
Too often, people have a tendency of holding things in. Sometimes this can be good; there is a time and a place for everything of course. But one must learn that while withholding information, you’re also not allowing the other person to understand your situation in a clear and meaningful way. We all have to be reminded, consistently, that we must ‘walk in another person’s shoes’ or to ‘see it from his/her perspective’. But in normal, everyday life we tend to become wrapped up in our own lives and only see how things affect us instead of what was affecting the other person to make them behave in that way.
Let me give you an example. Close your eyes. Oh…wait, you can’t read this if you do. Sigh.
Ok, close your MENTAL eye and create a blank surface for me to paint on. Ready? Good.
Picture a young child in a bright red jumper. The child is standing on the sidewalk of a pretty and tree-lined neighborhood. The child is bouncing a yellow ball. Now picture a dog. The dog has just come from around the street corner, where every day for the past four months three young boys have thrown rocks at the dog, chased it and hit it with sticks. But first it’s always the throwing of rocks. Now picture the dog coming down the side-walk and seeing the child with the ball. The bouncing ball. The child see’s the dog and wants to play. “Here doggy! Catch!” and so the child throws the ball in the general direction of the dog. And the dog experiences the straw that broke the camel’s back and chases the child, barking and growling.
Who shall the child be mad at? The dog? How about her parents? Who shall the dog blame? Where do the boys come into play? The dog can’t explain the past torture of the boys to the child or the child’s parents. Or they don’t want to listen. So they abuse the dog.
Stop. Before we go further. Stop analyzing the above problem. I want to ask you a question. Describe what the child looks like. Is the child a boy or a girl? What color hair or eyes? Does the red jumper have a design on it? How about the dog? What does it look like?
To me, the child is a little girl in a bright red corduroy jumper and long sleeve white cotton turtleneck because it’s cold out. She has dark brown hair that falls down her back and throws back streaks of gold and red as the sun hits it. The dog is small in size, with a sweet and calm Benji look-alike demeanor. The trees in the neighborhood are large and old but in colors of autumn; reds, gold, oranges.
I’ll bet that you and I saw two totally different scenes but we still got the gist of the situation. Maybe you pictured what the boys looked like more and the action between the girl and the dog was faster, a blur, less in focus. Either way, we just communicated positively. That is not always the case. Sometimes, what I say you may not hear. Sometimes, I may think but not say. Sometimes, you may read into that.
Bad behavior by a few, assumptions by many, innocence by some. None really matter, when no one is willing to talk or listen. If all that’s done is yelling, screaming, verbal abuse, angry reactions or assumptions leading to abusive habits, then what can we possibly hope to accomplish? We’ve all been guilty of forgetting the other side.
Because the Indian culture is so wrapped around the family dynamics, it’s difficult for parents to break the cycle of thousands of years of tradition. It becomes easier with each new generation exposed to outside influences, but still difficult.
I feel we are lucky; Bear’s parents try so hard to see the other path, other ways, or to try new traditions. But they are parents and as such they can try to rule over their children, even adult married children, when they see them having problems. When they feel they need to help in some way, with sage, time-tested advice, even when it comes across sounding like a demand, even when it feels controlling.
The crucial part here is to understand why they feel the need to express them this way and react to that understanding instead of the actual occurrence.
I understand that his parents love and care for all of us so very much, that they try to become super human in order to protect us. They have their own fears and so try to push us to fix issues we understand when they don’t. To them, the unknown is too scary, too unpredictable and too likely to hurt. So, the answer is to go the tried and true route. And they will argue this and argue this and argue this.
“Stay calm. Breathe. Deep breaths. They love so they do. Calm.”
What? You think I don’t want to explode sometimes? Of course I do! I’m human! But does exploding do anything? Not to my knowledge it doesn’t. So I stick to my mantra as often as possible whenever they get nervous, afraid and pushy. Because I know that they are doing it out of love.
So the next time someone says or does something that makes you angry or upset or hurts your feelings. Stop before you react. Don’t perpetuate the situation. Breathe. Stay calm. Try to see their point of view and if you can’t, then ask them. Talk to them. Get to the root of the problem. And then work together to fix it.
Communicate.
And then go and eat a PB&J sandwich.
And I leave you with some rather profound, in my opinion, quotes on Communication.
~ It seemed rather incongruous that in a society of super sophisticated communication, we often suffer from a shortage of listeners. ~ Erma Bombeck
~ The most important things are the hardest to say, because words diminish them. ~ Stephen King
~ We have two ears and one mouth so that we can listen twice as much as we speak. ~ Epictetus
~ The way we communicate with others and with ourselves ultimately determines the quality of our lives ~ Anthony Robbins
Like this:
Be the first to like this post.